Fannie & Freddie Just Shook Up Credit Scoring

1. Breaking the FICO Monopoly: VantageScore 4.0 Approved for Mortgages

On July 8, 2025, the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) officially approved the use of VantageScore 4.0 for mortgages purchased by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. This marks a major shift in the mortgage industry, where FICO had long been the dominant—and often sole—credit scoring model accepted by the government-sponsored enterprises (GSEs). Lenders may now use VantageScore 4.0 alongside FICO when evaluating borrowers for conventional home loans.

Key reasons this change matters:

• It creates competition in credit scoring, potentially lowering costs for lenders and borrowers alike.
• VantageScore 4.0 includes rent, utility, and telecom payment history—offering a more inclusive picture of creditworthiness.
• Lenders can continue using existing tri-merge credit reports, easing the transition without major infrastructure changes.

2. How VantageScore 4.0 Helps More Buyers Qualify

VantageScore 4.0 expands access to credit by factoring in alternative data and reducing barriers for those with limited credit histories. Borrowers who previously couldn’t qualify using FICO—due to short credit histories or reliance on non-traditional payment types—may now become eligible for a home loan under the new model.

Who benefits from the shift:

• First-time buyers with thin credit files or strong rent payment histories.
• Consumers in underserved communities, including veterans and rural residents.
• Up to 5 million potential borrowers who were previously excluded under FICO-only models.

3. What Lenders and the Market Are Saying

The response from the lending industry has been largely positive. Credit unions and community lenders welcome the reduced costs, as FICO score access fees have risen significantly. Meanwhile, market analysts expect the change to spur innovation in mortgage underwriting.

Industry reactions and market impact:

• FICO’s stock dropped ~9% following the announcement, signaling market concerns about losing dominance.
• Financial institutions praised the FHFA for maintaining the existing tri-merge credit infrastructure.
• Experts expect a gradual rollout as lenders test and adapt to dual-score underwriting models.

4. What This Means for You as a Buyer

This move could make it easier—and more affordable—for buyers to qualify for a mortgage, especially if they have limited or unconventional credit histories. As lenders adopt VantageScore 4.0, consumers should understand how it differs from FICO and ask how each model may affect their loan options.

Steps to take now:

• Ask your lender whether they accept VantageScore 4.0 for pre-approval.
• Check your VantageScore (many free credit monitoring services offer it).
• If you pay rent, utilities, or phone bills on time—this shift could improve your chances of qualifying.

5. The Bigger Picture: A More Inclusive Mortgage Market

The FHFA’s decision supports a more equitable housing finance system by allowing diverse data to influence credit scores. It fulfills a mandate from the Credit Score Competition Act of 2018 and is projected to open the door to up to $1 trillion in additional mortgage originations over time. While adoption will take time, the move sets a precedent for broader credit access and innovation in the mortgage space.

Why this is a win for homebuyers:

• More inclusive credit evaluation means more people can access homeownership.
• Lenders benefit from lower costs and increased competition in scoring models.
• It modernizes an outdated system and reflects real-world financial behavior better than traditional models alone.

Conclusion

The approval of VantageScore 4.0 marks a historic shift in mortgage lending. By enabling alternative data and expanding credit access, this change empowers millions of potential buyers to pursue homeownership with a fairer, more accurate credit evaluation. As lenders begin implementing the new model, buyers should stay informed, ask questions, and explore how this opportunity might work in their favor.

Next Article: The 20% Down Payment Myth
Previous Article: Why Mortgage Rates Rise and Fall — The Economic Forces Behind Your Loan Cost